On Saturday, the Mets traded closer Jeurys Familia to the Oakland Athletics. As we Mets fans close the book on the Familia era, I would like to make the case that he was a much better postseason pitcher the average Mets fan thinks he was.
Most often, when analyzing how good a player/pitcher somebody is/was, it is valid to look at the player’s career cumulative statistics. While stats never tell the full picture, a large enough sample size of statistics does not lie either. That said, for Jeurys Familia, we clearly do not have a large enough sample size to judge his postseason career on his cumulative save totals. Familia is 5 for 8 in postseason save chances. Thus, he has three career blown saves in the postseason. Additionally, those three blown saves came in the World Series; thus, four of his past five postseason appearances yielded three blown saves (all in the World Series) and a loss in the 2016 Wild Card game.
However, the guy has all of 13 career playoff appearances. With a number that small, it is more logical to examine his performance on a game-by-game basis than a cumulative basis. At the same time, it is worth noting that his playoff ERA is 2.30, and his playoff WHIP is an incredible .638! Those two numbers should give you pause when deriding the guy’s playoff career. More importantly, let us examine his 13 playoff outings:
- 2015 NLDS Game 1 at Los Angeles: Familia pitches 1.1 innings with and retires all four batters he faces. He enters a 3-1 game in the 8th with two outs and a runner on base. At Dodger Stadium in this instance, many pitchers might struggle, but Familia does not. Familia is unfazed by the pressure and dominates.
- 2015 NLDS Game 3 vs. Los Angeles: Familia retires all 3 batters he faces in the 9th The inning begins with the Mets leading 13-4. After Erik Goeddel allows the first four batters to reach base, Familia comes on to stop the bleeding and preserve a 13-7 win. This is a low-pressure situation, but he is perfect nonetheless.
- 2015 NLDS Game 4 vs. Los Angeles: Familia pitches a perfect Top of the 9th to keep the Dodgers’ lead at 3-1. The Mets lose the game, but Familia remains perfect for his postseason career.
- 2015 NLDS Game 5 at Los Angeles: If you are a real Mets fan, you think after this game, “Oh my God, we might have our Mariano.” It is a winner-take-all game, and Familia pitches perfect 8th and 9th innings at Dodger Stadium with the Mets clinging to a 3-2 lead in the game. If Armando Benitez, John Franco, Braden Looper, Billy Wagner, or Francisco Rodriguez is the Mets’ pitcher this night; I think the Mets lose the game. Fortunately, Familia has ice water in his veins and finishes off one gem of a pitching performance for the Mets (6 gutty innings from Jacob deGrom and a solid relief inning from Noah Syndergaard).
- 2015 NLCS Game 1 vs. Chicago: Ho-hum: Familia records his third postseason save of more than one inning (1.1). This time, he does allow a hit, but he nevertheless preserves a 4-2 win for the Mets and Matt Harvey, who pitched 7.2 innings. (Side note: With all of the ridiculously short starting pitchers’ outings in the 2016 and 2017 postseasons, it is refreshing to remember that the Mets’ starters routinely pitched at least 6 innings and often more during the 2015 playoffs.)
- 2015 NLCS Game 2 vs. Chicago: Ho-hum again: Familia records his first easy (in my opinion) save of the postseason. He allows 1 hit over 1 inning in preserving a 4-1 Mets win. Even Trevor Hoffman probably could have converted this save.
- 2015 NLCS Game 3 at Chicago: Another easy one: Familia pitches a perfect ninth to finish off a 5-2 Mets win.
- 2015 NLCS Game 5 at Chicago: Familia earns the right to be on the mound as the Mets clinch their first pennant in 15 years. He pitches a scoreless 9th and walks one batter. The Mets win 8-3.
Therefore, as we presently stand, Familia has put together 8 scoreless appearances with only 3 baserunners allowed. He is 5-for-5 in save opportunities, with 3 of those saves being more than one inning long. Anyway, back to the log.
- 2015 World Series Game 1 at Kansas City: Familia enters in the 8th inning with the tying run on base. Familia records the last out of the inning but allows a game-tying solo homer to Alex Gordon in the 9th Thus, Familia’s line is 1.1 innings, 1 ER, 1 baserunner (the homer), 1 blown save. It is the first blemish on Familia’s postseason record. The Mets lose the game in 14 innings.
- 2015 World Series Game 3 vs. Kansas City: Familia pitches a perfect 9th to preserve a 9-3 Mets win and to give the Mets their first win of the World Series. In hindsight, people criticize manager Terry Collins for using Familia with a 6-run lead. On one hand, Collins used Familia with a bigger lead in Game 3 of the NLDS, and Familia looked no worse for wear in Games 4 and 5 of that series. On the other hand, this World Series appearance represents Familia’s 10th postseason appearance in three weeks. Thus, fatigue is likely becoming a bigger factor. How does Familia respond going forward?…
- 2015 World Series Game 4 vs. Kansas City: Familia pitches 2/3 of an inning (8th inning), allowing an unearned run and two hits. This is where the raw stats do not tell the story. Mets fans know the story. Familia enters in the Top of the 8th with the Mets clinging to a 1-run lead. There are runners on 1st and 2nd with 1 out. Eric Hosmer hits a ground ball to second baseman Daniel Murphy. At worst, this should be a 4-3 ground out that puts runners at second and third with 2 outs. Instead, Murphy makes an error, allowing the tying run to score. Somehow, this alone already counts as a blown save for Familia. It is ridiculous that baseball scoring credits the run to the previous pitcher but the blown save to Familia, but I digress. There are now runners on 1st and 3rd with 1 out and a tie score. Familia allows two hits, and the two runners ultimately score (second being an unearned run charged to Familia). Mets lose 5-3.
Sure, Murphy’s error is not solely responsible for Familia’s two hits allowed. That said, Familia enters the game and induces the groundball he needed. Had there then instead been 2nd and 3rd with 2 outs and the Mets up by 1, things might go differently than with first and third, 1 out, and a tie game.
- 2015 World Series Game 5 vs. Kansas City: It is silly that Familia was given a blown save in Game 4 for allowing the inherited runner to score on Murphy’s error. It is criminal that Familia is given a blown save in the upcoming scenario. Mets fans know this one very, very well. Familia relieves Matt Harvey with the tying run on second and nobody out in the Top of the 9th. Familia induces consecutive groundouts. The first moves Eric Hosmer from second to third. The second groundout is 5-3, with David Wright throwing the ball over to Lucas Duda. Of course, Hosmer ends up following Wright and scoring the tying run on the play. Familia then induces a third-consecutive groundout.
Therefore, Jeurys Familia allows three consecutive groundouts and earns a blown save. Baseball’s rules are ridiculous. Anyway, as we exit the 2015 postseason, we should remember Familia as being a great postseason pitcher. Yes, he technically blew three saves, but two were fully or partially because of errors…and one was because baseball’s “blown save” crediting is silly. In truth; over 12 playoff appearances, Alex Gordon’s Game 1 (WS) homer and the two KC hits after Murphy’s error opened the door were the only negatives on the guy’s record. Familia had a stellar postseason and was instrumental in the Mets making it to the World Series.
However, after Familia’s unlucky-13th postseason appearance, many Mets fans retroactively decide that Familia is a bad postseason pitcher. Of course, in this last appearance, Familia enters a scoreless game in the 9th inning and allows two baserunners before allowing Conor Gillaspie’s game-winning homer. This is easily Familia’s worst postseason moment. Unfortunately, it is his last Mets postseason moment, but let us not forget that the guy was actually a fantastic postseason pitcher for most of his Mets career.