How I Made the Cincinnati Reds World Series Champs After One Season

If you’ve never tried this before, I 12/10 recommend it.  All you need is about $350 dollars to purchase a PS4 and The Show.  Once that’s done, go to Season mode, choose a horrible, horrible team (ie: Cincinnati Reds) and quickly do everything you can to bring a title to their miserably failing city. To do this properly, you can’t put on force trades, and you can’t put on unlimited budget, that’s like juicing in the GM world.  It ruins the integrity and makes everything less fun (although baseball on steroids was un-fucking-real).

It basically comes down to making great trades, signing free agents, and flipping talent and prospects for WIN NOW-caliber players.

The Reds had a problem everywhere other than 1B (Joey Votto), 2B (Jose Peraza), CF (Billy Hamiltion), and C (Devin Mesoraco), so I had a lot of work to do:

TRADES (for 2017 season)

Acquired SP Sonny Gray for CP Raisel Igelias, SP Brandon Finnegan, and 2B Tony Renda

Acquired 3B Maikel Franco for CF Arismendy Alcantra, 3B Eugenio Suarez, and SP Homer Bailey

Acquired SP Seth Lugo for RF Patrick Kvelehan, SP Cody Reed, and RP Blake Wood

Acquired SP Jordan Zimmerman for SP Robert Stephenson and SS Zack Cozart

Acquired CF George Springer for CF Billy Hamilton and RP Drew Storen

FREE AGENT SIGNINGS (for 2017 season)

Signed RP Joe Blanton

Signed SS Alexei Ramirez

Signed C Blair Jimenez


After all that we finished 30 games under .500, but held much promise to our next season. We had a lot less holes to fill, and I planned on working on some free agent flipping to get some talent.

FREE AGENT SIGNINGS (for 2018 season)

Signed SP Jeremy Hellickson

Signed 3B Adrian Beltre

The free agent season didn’t work out as well as I wanted because no matter how much money I offered players, nobody wanted to play in Cincinnati. Alas, I plunged forward.

TRADES (for 2018 season)

Acquired SP Jose Quintana and SS Jody Getz for C Devin Mesoraco, SP Seth Lugo, and RP Michael Lorenzen

Acquired SS Jean Segura and CF Jarrody Dyson for 3B Adrian Beltre, SP Kirby St. John, and SP Joel Benjamin

The “Adrian Beltre Move” is essentially a glitch in the game because I paid him $12.8 mil to be a DH on a National League team, but when the trade deadline came, people were willing to give up an arm and a leg for the 38 year old batting .210. Whatever.

So here was my starting lineup going into the second half of the 2018 season:

  1. Jean Segura SS
  2. George Springer CF
  3. Joey Votto 1B
  4. Maikel Franco 3B
  5. Adam Duvall RF
  6. Jarrod Dyson LF
  7. Blair Jimenez C
  8. Jose Peraza 2B
  9. DH/SP

And here was my pitching staff

  1. Sonny Gray
  2. Jose Quintana
  3. Jordan Zimmerman
  4. Jeremy Hellickson
  5. Anthony DeSclafani


We won the NL Central by 3 games over the Cubs, and I beat the Astros in 7 games in a 6-1 victory to win the World Series, where Quintana threw 8 great innings and George Springer and Adam Duvall both homered.

In case you needed proof

I gave up pretty much my whole farm system and I had literally one good prospect left, but that’s the price of being a win-now team. My thanks go out to the Reds players who played well above expectation (Jeremy Hellickson went 18-2 with a 2.11 ERA and Blair Jimenez was Rookie of the Year in 2017, making it possible to trade Mesoraco for Quintana) and also Adrian Beltre. I have no idea why you are valued so incredibly high, but The Show seems to think you are worth the world, so I’ll take it. Congratulations to the fake Cincinnati Reds on the totally not real title, and congratulations to me for being such a great GM. Take notes.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s